Blog

Where Upper West Side Condo Buyers Signed Over the Summer

On July 7, 2026, apartment 15B at 250 West 96th Street was listed and went into contract the same day at $2.65 million. Three weeks later, on July 28, it closed for $2,583,750, or $2,017 a square foot, according to Marketproof's sale record. That price was 3% below the original ask. The building had been selling for four years by then.

The deal is small, but it shows where Upper West Side condo demand went in the third quarter of 2026. Contracts didn't go to the newest towers or the highest floors. They went to buildings that had been on the market for years, at prices well below the Manhattan new-development average. A buyer comparing neighborhoods this winter can treat the Upper West Side condo market as three rungs on a price-per-foot ladder. Each rung moves on its own schedule, and from July through September the lower two moved.

Manhattan's new-development market had a slow third quarter

The citywide numbers set the scene. From July through September 2026, Manhattan new-development contracts fell 30% year over year, from 331 to 240. Contract volume fell 13% to $961 million, based on Brown Harris Stevens Development Marketing data reported by The Real Deal. The average closed price for new development in that quarter held roughly flat year over year at about $2,070 a square foot.

Weak demand doesn't explain the drop. The same Real Deal report put the cause on supply: the roughly 3,000 new-development units on the Manhattan market in Q3 2026 were 30% below the borough's 10-year average. Only 360 new units across 10 Manhattan buildings came to market that quarter. Resale went the other way. Brick Underground's third-quarter report found Manhattan co-op and condo deals up 8% year over year in Q3 2026, with the median sale price unchanged from Q2 at $1.25 million. Listings were down 10.7% from a year earlier, and luxury listings were down 14.1%.

So buyers were active and inventory was short. The Real Deal reported that many of the quarter's top-selling condos were "boutique launches or older buildings catching a second wind against reduced competition." Brown Harris Stevens Development Marketing's Robin Schneiderman said projects with entry-level pricing did especially well because "that segment of the market is starving for inventory." Two of the buildings The Real Deal named sit on the Upper West Side, and they are the bottom two rungs of the ladder.

The bottom rung is a 1960s tower on West 68th Street

Dorchester Towers, at 155 West 68th Street between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue, isn't new construction. It was built in the 1960s, became a condominium in 1984, and was the first major development by Paul and Seymour Milstein, according to West Side Rag. The building covers more than 600,000 square feet and has nearly 700 apartments. The Milstein family's firm, Ogden CAP Properties, kept about half of them as sponsor-owned units after the condo conversion.

In 2024, Ogden CAP put 324 of those apartments up for sale as a $375 million offering. Tenants got the first chance to buy, then other residents, and the units opened to outside buyers that June. The Real Deal's 2024 coverage gave asking ranges of $980 to $1,600 a square foot for studios, $1,100 to $1,700 for one-bedrooms and $1,100 to $1,750 for two-bedrooms.

Two years later, the offering is still selling. The building added 15 contracts in the third quarter of 2026, and the units on offer averaged an asking price of $1,402 a square foot, per Corcoran Sunshine figures cited by The Real Deal. That was among the strongest quarterly contract counts in Manhattan, at roughly two-thirds of the borough's new-development average price per foot. It also fits Schneiderman's point about the entry-level segment exactly. In an Upper West Side condo, $1,402 a foot buys a studio or one-bedroom at a price that much of the newer stock can't match.

The middle rung is four years into sales at 96th and Broadway

Up Broadway, JVP Management's 96+Broadway at 250 West 96th Street is the middle rung. The 23-story building was designed by Thomas Juul-Hansen, with a stone façade and stepped terraces. It launched sales in August 2022 with one-bedrooms from $1.395 million, two-bedrooms from $2.635 million, three-bedrooms from $3.535 million and four-bedrooms from $5.15 million.

In the third quarter of 2026, the 130-unit building signed 13 contracts and reached two-thirds sold, The Real Deal reported. Units ranged from $1.3 million for a one-bedroom to just under $12 million for a four-bedroom penthouse. Apartment 15B's $2,017 a square foot puts this rung about $50 a foot below the Manhattan new-development average for the quarter. The building's entry price has stayed where it started. A one-bedroom at about $1.3 million in The Real Deal's October report is roughly where the launch sheet began in 2022.

That matters for what "older buildings catching a second wind" means here. At 96+Broadway, the second wind didn't come from a price cut. The building held its pricing for four years while newer competition thinned out. 15B traded 3% under its original ask, a modest discount on a two-bedroom that went from listing to closing in three weeks.

The top rung did its selling in the spring

The ladder's top rung is Extell's 50 West 66th Street, the 39-story, Snøhetta-designed tower off Central Park West. Its busy stretch came earlier in the year. In the week of April 6 to 12, 2026, buyers signed 38 Manhattan contracts asking $4 million or more. Twelve were for Upper West Side condos, and the most expensive was Unit 40N at 50 West 66th, a 3,400-square-foot four-bedroom asking $23.5 million, according to The Real Deal. As of that April report, 90 of the tower's 121 units had recorded sales since closings began, averaging about $3,700 a square foot. They included Unit 52E at $55.6 million.

In June 2026, Unit 40W closed for $17.1 million. The roughly 2,800-square-foot apartment sold for more than $500,000 above its last asking price, and The Real Deal reported the building was over 80% sold. These are spring figures, and they describe a building already deep into its sellout. Nothing from 50 West 66th appeared among the third quarter's reported top sellers.

So by the end of September, the ladder had a clear shape. The top rung, at about $3,700 a foot recorded, sold strongly in the first half of 2026 with little inventory left. The middle rung, at about $2,000 a foot, and the bottom rung, at about $1,400, carried the neighborhood's contract activity through the summer.

What the ladder tells a buyer comparing neighborhoods

The Upper West Side has a range of newer condo stock, at very different prices per foot, within about 30 blocks of Broadway. The three buildings above span roughly $1,400 to $3,700 a square foot. A single neighborhood condo figure averages these markets together. A median from a quarter heavy with Dorchester contracts will look very different from one that includes a spring of 50 West 66th closings, even if nothing about any one building has changed.

For a buyer, the practical point is that competition on the Upper West Side depends on which rung you're shopping. Under $2 million, the third-quarter evidence points to a crowded segment. Brokers are calling entry-level inventory scarce across Manhattan, and two Upper West Side buildings pricing below or near the borough average signed 28 contracts between them in one quarter. A two-bedroom that went from listing to closing in three weeks at 3% under its original ask fits that pattern. Near the top, where 50 West 66th had sold more than 80% of its units by June, the question is less about price and more about which units are still left.

The same lens works when you set the Upper West Side against downtown or Midtown options. Comparing one neighborhood's blended median with another's tells you little. A better comparison is a 1960s tower with full-service condo ownership at about $1,400 a foot, a 2022 boutique building at about $2,000, and a park-adjacent tower recording near $3,700, each against whatever sits at the same rung elsewhere. Readers weighing condo ownership against a co-op can start with our guide to co-ops vs. condos on the Upper West Side. Readers coming from Lower Manhattan may want our notes on moving from downtown to the Upper West Side.

A few questions buyers ask about this market

Is Dorchester Towers a new building? No. It was built in the 1960s and converted to a condominium in 1984. The units selling now are the sponsor's retained apartments, which Ogden CAP began marketing in 2024.

Did the Upper West Side buck the Manhattan slowdown? Its top-selling buildings did well in a quarter when Manhattan new-development contracts fell 30% year over year. The Real Deal and Brown Harris Stevens Development Marketing tied that citywide drop to short supply, not weak demand.

Where does the Upper West Side sit against the Manhattan average? The Manhattan new-development average closed price in Q3 2026 was about $2,070 a square foot. 96+Broadway trades close to that figure, Dorchester Towers asks well below it, and 50 West 66th has recorded well above it.

If you're weighing a specific rung of this ladder, from a first condo near Lincoln Center to a park-view residence off Central Park West, The Antigua Team can walk you through the buildings at that price per foot and what has traded there recently. Out-of-state and international buyers can start with our Global VIP Client Program. Request your Global VIP consultation.

Work With Us

Professional and knowledgeable, The Antigua Team are known for avoiding pitfalls, overcoming challenges, and securing big wins.
Contact Us
Follow Us